InsureShield & CommerceShield for Shopify

InsureShield & CommerceShield

Manage fraud, shipping, and checkout risk in one app
Rating
3.8
Feedback
41
Reviews
Chart
#2,385
Shopify
Reviews over time
New reviews per month across the app's lifetime.
App ranking
Overall position in the Shopify App Store.
Reviews summary

The reviews for this Shopify App, InsureShield, are quite polarized. On the positive side, many users appreciate the ease of making claims, the responsiveness of customer support, and the peace of mind it provides for protecting shipments. Users have mentioned that the app has helped them cover damage and losses that carrier insurance would not pay out. Additionally, some users have praised the professionalism of the team and the quick resolution of cases. However, on the negative side, there are complaints about denied claims, issues with the app being buggy and transactions not loading, delays in support responses, and changes in policy that users found unreasonable. Some users also mentioned confusion regarding charges and limitations in coverage for orders from sources other than Shopify. Overall, while some users highly recommend the app for its efficiency and customer service, others have had frustrating experiences with denied claims and technical issues.

Time spent using app
How long merchants keep the app installed.
Less than an hour 0%
Less than a day 0%
Less than a month 7%
Less than a year 76%
More than a year 17%
All reviews
1 / 5 Share
Jan. 12, 2026

This app and company just keeps getting worse. We have been having claims denied for no reason at all. Sometimes tracking clearly shows it was lost, sometimes it shows it was delivered and we have written affidavit from the customer that it was not, or was stolen. Sometimes even delivered to wrong address. In any case, they will find any reason they can to deny your claims. Customer support is not help at all and will essentially just forward your emails over to the same claims team that denied them. If you reach out to the claims adjusters, they simply tell you "this is staying closed". My last claim she flat out told me that USPS said the delivered it so it's denied. Ok, so why are you advertising that this protects against theft or packages that were misdelivered? In the month of December alone, we paid this company (UPS Capital, InsureShield, whatever they go by now), over $800, only for them to deny claims. To me, this is blatant fraud and honestly, we are considering legal action and may also have to talk to our bank about reversing that charge. It's not just these two claims, it's happened before and right now the cost does not justify the spotty coverage they are replying. Our recommendation, seek a different app. You won't be happy with this one (also, the shopify extension/app is extremely buggy and sometimes won't even show you transactions).

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Joco Records Over 4 years 15 3.5
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback, and we’re genuinely sorry for what you’ve experienced. We understand how frustrating inconsistent claim outcomes and app issues can be, and this is not the experience we aim to deliver. We’ve already put a team on it to investigate both the claim outcomes and the Shopify app issues you mentioned. A team member will reach out directly to collect details and work toward a resolution. We truly appreciate you bringing this to our attention.

5 / 5 Share
April 20, 2024

muy buena y muy rapida la resolucion de casos de reclamos, Fue muy buena decision de nuestra compañia tomar la cobertura de seguro de envios. gracias por atencion. Mil veces recomendado

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
AAA Craft Wire 5 months 3 5.0
Developer Reply

Hola AAA Craft Wire, gracias por esta increíble reseña y por recomendar la aplicación InsureShield. Priorizamos excelentes experiencias de envío y estamos seguros de que cumplimos con los requisitos aquí para usted. ¡Por un feliz envío!

5 / 5 Share
April 18, 2024

Absolutely love using this app, it's so easy to use and customer support is top notch. Thank you very much.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Charmboxmen 5 months 4 5.0
Developer Reply

Hi Charmboxmen, We’re glad that you’re loving our InsureShield app! Our goal is to provide great customer service to our customers and we are glad to hear that you’re having a great experience with our support team.

5 / 5 Share
April 15, 2024

A solid 5 stars, really good insurance for our orders, it's been around 2months we are using this and also the customer support is great they reply with a day or so

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Olfactoryfactoryllc About 2 months 2 5.0
Developer Reply

That’s what we call the brighter side of shipping! We are so glad to hear that you’ve been enjoying the InsureShield app & had a positive experience with our customer success team.

1 / 5 Share
May 5, 2024

I would not recommend this app at all. After using it for 7 months and only submitted 5 claims, they've decided to change my policy and told me that they were going to deduct $50 from every claim refund on top of what they're already charging me and my customers. The most absurd thing I've heard. But luckily, there's plenty of fish in the sea so I found me a much better app on the app store that doesn't have these ridiculous terms. Keep looking, there are way better apps out there than Insure Shield.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Developer Reply

Hi Exquisite Designs Home Décor, thank you for the wonderful review, we are glad that you enjoyed our customer support team & our quick claims process! We’d like to share that our coverage policies can help reimburse on shipping costs. If you have any questions on how to file a claim including shipping costs or review status of previous claims, please reach out to us at [email protected]. Thank you again for your review, any feedback is helpful to our team and helps us get better.

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.