Mystery Discount & Free Gift for Shopify

Mystery Discount & Free Gift

Excite customers with mystery gifts & personalized discounts
Rating
4.4
Feedback
7
Reviews
Chart
#4,668
Shopify
Reviews over time
New reviews per month across the app's lifetime.
App ranking
Overall position in the Shopify App Store.
Reviews summary

The reviews for this Shopify app are mixed, with both positive and negative aspects highlighted by users. On the positive side, users appreciate the engaging features such as the mystery discount and free gift options. The app is praised for its ability to make promotions more exciting and drive conversions effectively. Users also find the app easy to set up and manage, with no unnecessary complexity. However, there are concerns raised about the 'Mystery Discount' feature being broken, leading to trust issues with customers. Additionally, the lack of translation options for multilingual sites makes it challenging for international brands to use the app.

Time spent using app
How long merchants keep the app installed.
Less than an hour 14%
Less than a day 0%
Less than a month 43%
Less than a year 29%
More than a year 0%
All reviews
1 / 5 Share
May 4, 2026

We had high hopes for this app, but the 'Mystery Discount' feature is fundamentally broken. The app 'locks in' a promo code on a user’s first visit (which support confirmed), yet if the user refreshes the page, the popup displays a completely different discount percentage. This creates a massive trust issue with customers who think they are getting one deal only to have another applied at checkout. Beyond the technical glitches, the app is not ready for international brands; there are no translation options for multilingual sites. Avoid this if you value consistency and customer trust.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Les Garçons 3 3.7
5 / 5 Share
April 17, 2026

We installed this app for both the mystery discount and free gift features, and it’s been a great experience so far. It gave us a more engaging way to run promotions and helped make the offer feel more exciting than a standard discount.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Great Gums 4 days 1 5.0
5 / 5 Share
March 31, 2026

amazing app. works as promised. like it!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
SIRAATSKITCHEN 1 minute 7 5.0
5 / 5 Share
March 31, 2026

We’ve been using this app for the past 2 months, and the automatic mystery gift added to the cart has made a real difference. It has contributed to a significant increase in our sales.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Swift Running About 1 month 11 4.9
5 / 5 Share
March 25, 2026

We’ve been using this at Strong Jaw and it’s been very straightforward to set up and manage. No unnecessary complexity. Does what it’s supposed to. The gift-with-purchase functionality has directly improved our conversion rate, and we’ve seen a big lift since adding it. The mystery discount feature is also a solid feature. It gives us another way to drive conversions without needing to run constant blanket discounts. Overall, it looks clean, it's reliable, and it works well. If you’re looking for a simple way to increase conversions with GWP or discount-based offers, this is an easy recommendation.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Strong Jaw Supplements 9 days 2 5.0

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.