Whatnot
The reviews are mixed, but they lean negative overall because several merchants ran into serious workflow and syncing problems. Positive feedback focuses on how easy the app is to set up, how well it can move inventory from Shopify into Whatnot, and how responsive the Whatnot team has been in improving the integration. A few reviewers also reported that it works reliably at scale, with thousands of orders processed successfully and no need for manual inventory adjustments. The negative reviews are more frequent and more specific. Merchants complained about one-way syncing limitations, broken or unreliable order import toggles, shipping profile imports that caused incorrect shipping charges, lack of Shopify Markets support, and missing controls for pricing changes or category edits. Several users felt the app was too restrictive for real-world selling needs, especially for sellers who want to manage inventory in both directions, run sales, or customize product categorization. Overall, the app appears promising and useful for some stores, but the current feature gaps and sync issues are causing frustration for others.
Review RSS feed
Makes it easy to get your Shopify inventory into Whatnot. That's where the good part of this app ends. It also imports your Shopify shipping profiles without any way to stop that. And there was no indication that would happen either. My first show had all the shipping costs totally F'd up as a result and likely cost me bidders and ultimately money as everyone was charged too much for shipping. The toggle to import orders into Shopify doesn't seem to work. I have it off, orders from Whatnot still imported into my Shopify after the show. As a result they also imported into PirateShip and clogged up my view with all the orders that I actually need to post from Whatnot. Looks like I will have to get rid of this app and just manually list stuff going forward.
Doesn't support Shopify Market, so if you live in Canada and your store default is in US, it won't work, they will force you to change your default currency, which doesn't make sense, or will tell you to setup a new store. They need to implement Shopify Market API to their app.
Installed it just to write a review ... Claude can create an MCP to do all of this with whatnot.. SO your 11% fee just convinced me to do just that.
I like it but it doesn't give any option to change the categories and keeps reading the categories wrong and putting women's clothes and others because it doesn't know how to read things like pants and dresses as women's clothes. I would be happy to manually change it and whatnot itself but there seems to be no option to bulk edit category
Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates
Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.