8Sunsets review for Judge.me Product Reviews App
Feb. 11, 2026
Judge.me states that their app integrates fully with Etsy to sync reviews from Etsy to Shopify. We contacted Judge.me support and demonstrated to them that their API does not work. It has been one week and there has yet to be any status update on whether or not they are working to correct this issue...horrible customer support and poor responsiveness.
We’re sorry for the frustration this caused and completely understand how critical reliable syncing is when integrating Etsy with Shopify. There was indeed an issue affecting the Etsy API connection, which has since been resolved. After fixing that, reviews began syncing again. However, we identified a separate limitation related to SKU mapping: Judge.me currently supports one-to-one SKU matching between Etsy and Shopify. When multiple Etsy listings share the same SKU, reviews can overwrite each other instead of syncing separately. We’ve worked closely with you to fully reset the integration, remove previously imported reviews, and prepare for a clean resync once SKU renumbering is complete. We’re currently awaiting your confirmation to reconnect and will actively monitor the next import to ensure it runs smoothly. We appreciate the detailed feedback, it has also helped us improve our documentation around SKU mapping limitations.
Collect unlimited product reviews, star ratings, testimonials