Pots & Pans Pie Co. review for Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program

March 19, 2025

Huge shout out to Daniel for all his help! He was there for me every step of the way and definitely went above and beyond in making sure I had everything I needed. I transitioned from Square POS to Shopify POS earlier this year, and I knew that one of the biggest hurdles would be converting our loyalty program over. We had 14,000 loyalty customers, so there was absolutely no way we could do it manually. I did research on 13 different loyalty apps (and downloaded most of them to test them out) because our customers loved the way our Square loyalty program was set up. About 85% of our transactions are in-person, and it was very important to get everything as close to the old system as possible. Joy was the only app that was customizable enough, yet simple enough, to match exactly what we needed. Because of the awesome features, we were able to revamp our program while still keeping the old rewards redemption process in place. It has been a fantastic experience! We went 2 months without a loyalty program and our sales decreased about 5-10% from the previous year. When we brought it back, our numbers went back to normal. Joy is a powerful system and it's keeping our customers satisfied - there's no doubt about it!