Magical Make an Offer for Shopify

Magical Make an Offer

Best Offer App • Bargain, Negotiate + Pay What You...
Developer
Magical Apps
View on App Store
Magical Make an Offer
Rating
4.7
Feedback
169
Reviews
Chart
#851
Shopify
Reviews over time
New reviews per month across the app's lifetime.
App ranking
Overall position in the Shopify App Store.
Reviews summary

The Magical Make An Offer app has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from users, with many praising its effectiveness and the exceptional customer support provided by the team. Users have highlighted the app's ability to generate extra income, ease of use, and quick setup process. The customer service team, particularly individuals like Jeff, Kyle, and Saad, has been commended for their responsiveness, knowledge, and willingness to assist with any issues or customization requests. Additionally, users appreciate the app's feature that allows customers to negotiate prices, leading to increased sales and customer engagement. However, there are a few negative reviews mentioning issues such as pricing discrepancies, lagging performance, and concerns about email notifications being sent from the app instead of the store owner.

Time spent using app
How long merchants keep the app installed.
Less than an hour 1%
Less than a day 9%
Less than a month 21%
Less than a year 44%
More than a year 17%
All reviews
5 / 5 Share
Sept. 11, 2026

This is a great app that does it's job well, with a minimum of fuss. It was easy to integrate into our custom theme, and has been working without any major issues ever since (which is to say, for quite some time). On the odd occasion that we've needed to contact support they've been responsive and helpful.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Betel Restored Furniture About 1 year 1 5.0
5 / 5 Share
April 16, 2026

Outstanding app and support. Jeff at Magical was excellent!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
GILMORE About 21 hours 1 5.0
Developer Reply

Glad I could get those make an offer buttons live on your paintings. I'm here if you need anything. -Jeff

5 / 5 Share
Jan. 29, 2026

Effective app with excellent support.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Le Shoppe Modern Almost 5 years 1 5.0
Developer Reply

Awesome to hear. Almost 5 years of helping you negotiate more sales and still going strong. We're here if you need us.

5 / 5 Share
Jan. 28, 2026

I’ve been using Magical Make An Offer for a little while now and the app itself works brilliantly. It does exactly what it’s supposed to and adds real value to my store. When switching themes, there were a couple of small issues — nothing major and certainly nothing to gripe about. What impressed me was the customer service. Support was immediate, knowledgeable, and fixed the issue straight away. A couple of hours later I noticed something else that needed adjusting, reached out again, and bang — sorted immediately. I can absolutely handle the odd hiccup with apps, especially when the customer service is this responsive and on point. Excellent support like this makes all the difference. Highly recommended.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
DT Collectable Toys 5 months 5 4.2
Developer Reply

Can't ask for more than that. Theme switches can get tricky but glad the team jumped in and got everything sorted fast.

5 / 5 Share
Jan. 23, 2026

Works great and getting a good response from our customers. Very glad we installed. Response from staff is excellent.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Signari Gallery About 2 months 1 5.0
Developer Reply

Good stuff right here. Customers engaging with offers and your team loving the experience, that's the perfect combo. Glad you installed.

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.