Magical Make an Offer
Overall, the reviews are overwhelmingly positive. Most merchants praise the app for doing exactly what it promises: letting customers make offers, negotiate prices, and helping stores capture sales they might otherwise lose. Many reviewers say it has directly increased conversions or revenue, is easy to use, integrates well with their theme, and can be customized to fit different store needs. Several also mention that it is especially valuable for niche use cases such as art, vintage items, donations, or stores wanting a pay-what-you-can style setup. The strongest recurring praise is for the support team. Reviewers repeatedly describe support as fast, responsive, knowledgeable, proactive, and willing to help with setup, coding, theme changes, and custom requests. A smaller set of negative comments mention pricing concerns, confusion about fees or usage charges, occasional lag or technical issues, limited customization options, and a few complaints about email branding or language availability. Even so, the overall sentiment is that the app is effective and well supported, with the main drawbacks centered on cost transparency and some feature limitations rather than core functionality.
Review RSS feed
I wanted visitors to login before being able to make an offer and the team helped me on the same day. The customer service is really on point. I wish them to grow by keeping the same mindset. I recommend the app.
We loved this review. We're absolutely going to maintain this mindset. Whatever our customers want and need to grow is important for us to deliver. Thank you!
Amazing staff, and the apps are just soooo good. I sell a LOT of art but as an artist I want my art to be accessible, allowing people to make an offer on my art has opened up a WORLD of opportunity for me. I am sooo glad I found this APP!!!! LETS GOOOOOO Check me out www.demir.shop
Awesome review. We're so happy to help you bring your art to the world with make an offer.
This is a great app that does it's job well, with a minimum of fuss. It was easy to integrate into our custom theme, and has been working without any major issues ever since (which is to say, for quite some time). On the odd occasion that we've needed to contact support they've been responsive and helpful.
Thanks for choosing to use our app. We're here if you need us.
Outstanding app and support. Jeff at Magical was excellent!
Glad I could get those make an offer buttons live on your paintings. I'm here if you need anything. -Jeff
Effective app with excellent support.
Awesome to hear. Almost 5 years of helping you negotiate more sales and still going strong. We're here if you need us.
Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates
Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.