Rating

4.0

feedback

164

Reviews

chart

#4,338

Shopify

Reviews Over Time

App Ranking

Time spent using app

  • Less than an hour
    2%
  • Less than a day
    4%
  • Less than a month
    15%
  • Less than a year
    43%
  • More than a year
    36%

Reviews Summary

Marsello, a loyalty program app for Shopify, has received mixed reviews from users. Positive aspects highlighted include responsive customer service, helpful support team members like Shanaya and Martin, and improvements in the app's features over time. Users appreciate the ease of use, integration with Shopify, and the combination of email, SMS marketing, and loyalty rewards in one platform. However, negative themes include high pricing, sudden rate increases, poor customer support experiences, bugs in the point system, and issues with data access and refunds. Some users felt that the app became unaffordable with pricing changes and expressed disappointment in the lack of flexibility and responsiveness from the company.

Highlights

Responsive customer service and helpful support team members like Shanaya and Martin
High pricing and sudden rate increases
Ease of use and integration with Shopify
Combination of email, SMS marketing, and loyalty rewards in one platform
Issues with bugs in the point system and data access

Rating Breakdown

  • 5
    77% (126 ratings)
  • 4
    5% (9 ratings)
  • 3
    4% (7 ratings)
  • 2
    1% (2 ratings)
  • 1
    12% (20 ratings)

Reviews with Text

  • 100% (164)
Review RSS Feed Review RSS Feed

All reviews

5 / 5 Share

Nov. 17, 2025

I have been with them for almost 10 years (since they were known as COLLECT loyalty). Highly professional team - and Roz and Vicky I have worked with are really great!

Using app

Almost 3 years

Total reviews

5

Average rating

5.0

1 / 5 Share

April 30, 2025

Disappointing Experience — Overpriced, No Refund, Poor Support We had a very bad experience with Marsello. They charged our business $300 CAD even though we never got to use the app. When we reached out within 30 days, explaining that we found their service too expensive for their poor features and wanted a refund, they outright refused. Their customer support was unhelpful and dismissive. Despite the fact that we hadn't benefited from the platform, they kept the full payment — which feels like they simply took our money without delivering value. For a loyalty program, their pricing is overrated and the service (poor features) does not match the cost. I strongly do not recommend Marsello to any business. Poor policies, bad customer experience, and no flexibility. Be careful before signing up — they do not stand behind their product.

Store

VAPEPUB

Using app

4 months

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0

1 / 5 Share

Dec. 16, 2024

Priced out of the app. I was a loyal user of this app, but they increased their rates while decreasing the benefits. As a struggling business, I could not afford the rate increase and lost all access to my customer data, including their loyalty points.

Using app

Over 5 years

Total reviews

6

Average rating

3.8

1 / 5 Share

March 21, 2025

Customer service is absolutely terrible. The experience has been disheartening and only foreshadows what is to come if we stay with them. We just signed up with Marsello and as soon as we became a paying customer, we couldn't get a hold of anyone. BEFORE signing up, I met with several staff members and they all seemed quite eager to help. Support does reply to our emails but the response time is usually about 6 or more hours. Even then, you reply and they don't get back to you for another few hours with a very generic response. How do you expect a business owner to sit tight while being kept in the dark? Customers have already signed up and waiting to use our loyalty program, only to be told it isn't working. This has a negative impact and only serves to discredit our business in the eyes of our customers. 'Ghosting us' speaks to their lack of professionalism as a whole. Their point system is buggy and it is evident. They haven't ironed out all the kinks. EDIT: The issue was escalated and the technical team took over. This are up and running now. EDIT: Now we are experiencing the same issue again and we are being ignored.

Using app

5 months

Total reviews

1

Average rating

1.0

5 / 5 Share

Nov. 8, 2024

Marsello has really improved and took into considerations our product requests. Martin does an excellent job communicating which is rare from other loyalty programs. The shopify integrations have improved. I highly recommend Marsello. We have tried every loyalty program on shopifys app store and they fit our needs best considering we lean heavier on in-store retail vs e-comm.

Using app

Over 2 years

Total reviews

1

Average rating

5.0

Developer Reply

Thank you so much for the kind feedback! We’re glad you’re enjoying the app’s omnichannel capabilities too - feedback like this is a real kick for us. Martin & The Marsello Team

All reviews

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more