All reviews

Rating Breakdown

  • 5
    77% (332 ratings)
  • 4
    9% (41 ratings)
  • 3
    7% (30 ratings)
  • 2
    3% (15 ratings)
  • 1
    3% (14 ratings)

Reviews with Text

  • 23% (100)
Review RSS Feed Review RSS Feed

1 / 5 Share

Feb. 5, 2026

I shipped $200 worth of goods, but it shows 'payment pending', and I have not received the money. I contacted Shopify, and they said the retailer did not have sufficient funds at the time of ordering. In that case, the order should not have been allowed in the first place. I sent the merchandise but did not receive payment. This app does not protect suppliers, and I do not recommend it.

Store

Bonmuz

Using app

5 months

Total reviews

4

Average rating

3.0

Developer Reply

We're sorry to hear this. After reviewing your account, we found that orders were fulfilled while still in 'Payment pending' status. Collective displays a pending icon on the order and includes a note recommending you wait until the order is marked as 'Paid' before shipping. For future orders, we recommend checking that orders show 'Paid' before fulfilling, or adjusting any automations you may have in place to exclude orders in 'Payment pending' status. If you need help adjusting your workflow, please reach out to our support team.

1 / 5 Share

Dec. 30, 2025

Allows anyone to buy ONE item for 50% off There should be MOQ requirements and I cannot turn this DAMN app off!! I do not want to use anymore!!!

Using app

About 2 months

Total reviews

1

Average rating

1.0

Developer Reply

We're sorry to hear you had an issue when using Collective. Please note that as the supplier you are able to set the product prices and the relevant retailer margins. Retailers can offer discounts on your products, but this comes out of their margins, not your cost price. If you are seeing differently within your admin, please contact Shopify Support as this should not be happening.

1 / 5 Share

Dec. 18, 2025

don't know why they switch to 75% profit unacceptable.

Using app

8 months

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0

Developer Reply

Thank you for the feedback. As a supplier, you can set retailer margins to retain full control over the cost price you receive when the item is purchased by the customer. We'll follow up with you over email to see if there's additional context we can gather about your situation.

1 / 5 Share

Dec. 12, 2025

It doesn’t work! Shows error message and impossible to uninstall Don’t install this app!!

Using app

2 days

Total reviews

5

Average rating

3.4

Developer Reply

Thank you for bringing this to our attention! Without being able to see your screen, we cannot say for sure what is happening. However this is absolutely not the expected before. We ask that you please contact Support if at all possible to correct the issue.

1 / 5 Share

Nov. 14, 2025

We really like the program, but the inability to separate shipping rates from our main store is a severe limitation. We want to extend a higher margin to Shopify collective shops; however, we offer free shipping on our site for orders over $100 and cannot separate that rate for collective orders. We would like to have shipping calculated at checkout for collective orders and have unique shipping rates for our store.

Using app

Over 2 years

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0

1 / 5 Share

Nov. 13, 2025

Using app

Over 2 years

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0

1 / 5 Share

Oct. 8, 2025

Using app

Over 2 years

Total reviews

1

Average rating

1.0

1 / 5 Share

Sept. 24, 2025

I was using this for a while, set up everything was great. Randomly, without any changes to my store, I was deemed ineligible. Shopify support doesn't know why I am ineligible, because I have met all the steps to be eligible. Therefore, this is a malfunctioning (half working) app that the developers apparently do not care to fix as I have reached out 4 times already and just did again today!

Using app

12 months

Total reviews

3

Average rating

1.0

1 / 5 Share

Sept. 4, 2025

Got an email today saying that Collective is now available globally, but guess what...my EU country is not actually eligible...so why bother sending invites for apps we do not qualify for???

Using app

11 minutes

Total reviews

11

Average rating

3.8

1 / 5 Share

Sept. 3, 2025

Why is this collective order free shipping - when i dont offer free shipping in the collective setting but only calculated shipping - We offer free shipping over RETAIL orders of $50+ - and and collective is providing free shipping for orders of $20 (with a $50 retail vLUE) - THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE

Using app

Over 1 year

Total reviews

6

Average rating

3.7

1 / 5 Share

Aug. 19, 2025

As a supplier my products aren't on "discovery". As a seller there is no "Discovery" of products to sell..... Outreach to suppliers/sellers via email? So US only ! Why did you sent me an email about this!

Using app

22 minutes

Total reviews

6

Average rating

3.7

1 / 5 Share

Aug. 17, 2025

It just does not work. It does not even open.

Store

The Qi

Using app

6 months

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0

1 / 5 Share

Aug. 16, 2025

Can not open, installed but nothing happens after that :(

Using app

3 minutes

Total reviews

1

Average rating

1.0

1 / 5 Share

July 16, 2025

too slow

Using app

About 1 year

Total reviews

2

Average rating

3.0