Judge.me Product Reviews App for Shopify

Judge.me Product Reviews App

Collect unlimited product reviews, star ratings, testimonials
Rating
5.0
Feedback
42,574
Reviews
Chart
#43
Shopify

All reviews

2 / 5 Share
July 8, 2026

Overall, I like the app, but the review system is far too restrictive and complicated. I have run into several issues: * When customers verify their email through the QR code or review request, they are taken to a ChargeMe account page where it looks like they already have an account. This is very confusing for customers. They only wanted to leave a review, not create or log into another platform. * Merchants have almost no control over reviews. Even small changes, such as anonymizing a customer’s name (changing a full surname to an initial), cannot be done by the merchant. The customer has to do everything themselves. * The review edit links are unreliable. When I tried to send one to a customer, it never arrived. * Overall, merchants cannot make even basic adjustments. Everything is locked down to such an extent that it no longer improves security—it just makes simple tasks slow and frustrating for both merchants and customers. I think the platform is overprotected. There should be more flexibility for store owners to manage reviews and help customers without forcing them through unnecessary steps. Right now, the process is much more complicated than it needs to be.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Tallio 4 months 1 2.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to leave such detailed feedback. We genuinely appreciate the balanced review and are glad to hear that, overall, you've been enjoying the app. We also understand the concerns you raised around the review confirmation flow, merchant controls, and the overall review management experience. Since your review, we've been in touch via email to discuss these points in more detail. Your suggestions regarding the reviewer profile page after email confirmation and giving merchants more flexibility for legitimate review management cases have already been shared with our Product team for consideration. We're also still keen to investigate the issue you mentioned with the review edit email not being delivered, as that isn't the experience we want anyone to have. If you have a chance to reply to our email with an example, we'll be happy to look into it for you. Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. Conversations like this genuinely help us improve Judge.me, and we hope we'll have the opportunity to make your experience even better over time.

2 / 5 Share
June 18, 2026

It's an ok app, but the reviews don't appear on safari because it's content is blocked. Largely useless imo.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
The Swedish Paintbrush About 2 months 3 3.7
2 / 5 Share
July 11, 2026

App broke the rich snippets by modifying the JSON-LD for most of my products in a way that Google Search did not recognize the product anymore. Use with caution.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Rare Parfum 3 months 14 2.8
2 / 5 Share
May 6, 2026

poco intuitiva

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Il mio negozio 2 months 140 4.9
Developer Reply

Grazie per il tuo feedback. Ci dispiace sapere che l’app ti sia sembrata poco intuitiva all’inizio. Abbiamo visto però che nel frattempo sei riuscito a contattare il nostro supporto e che il team ti ha aiutato a configurare correttamente i widget nelle pagine prodotto. Sappiamo che la fase iniziale può risultare un po’ tecnica in alcuni casi, ed è proprio per questo che il nostro team è sempre disponibile ad accompagnare i merchant passo dopo passo. Se dovessi avere altre domande o bisogno di ulteriore aiuto, saremo felici di assisterti.

2 / 5 Share
May 2, 2026

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Malbar et Sens About 2 months 1 2.0
Developer Reply

Merci pour votre retour. Nous avons depuis pu échanger ensemble par téléphone afin de vous accompagner sur la configuration de la langue en français, et nous sommes heureux d’avoir pu vous aider. N’hésitez pas à nous recontacter à tout moment si vous avez la moindre question, notre équipe sera toujours ravie de vous aider.

2 / 5 Share
April 21, 2026

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Zenora 8 days 8 4.6
2 / 5 Share
April 9, 2026

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Kaylulu 31 minutes 1 2.0
2 / 5 Share
April 6, 2026

incredibly frustrating to navigate

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Arizali About 1 year 2 2.5
Developer Reply

Thank you for your feedback, we’re sorry to hear the navigation felt frustrating. We understand how confusing it can be when things don’t behave consistently. We followed up with you and were able to clarify how to access the Reviews dashboard from the left-side menu. From our side, the section should always show all reviews, while the reports view is a separate page. That said, we understand you experienced some inconsistency, and we’re keeping an eye on this to better understand what might have caused it.

2 / 5 Share
March 17, 2026

still finding not easy for biginers

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
luxuriors 7 months 1 2.0
2 / 5 Share
Feb. 16, 2026

So far not a good experience. I will leave this review on until the issue is fixed. We have an e-commerce platform in CZ and the issue is that our customers get auto-replies and e-mails from Judge.me in Russian or Croatian language instead of Czech. I have already sent a ticket 2 times and so far no fix. Sadly, this makes our store look fraudulant. Thankfully, we are on the free version for now but I doubt that an upgrade would work if the codes are full of bugs in the trial version.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Mari Peče 8 months 4 4.3
Developer Reply

Thank you for raising this, you’re absolutely right that language accuracy is critical, especially for customer-facing emails. We sincerely apologise for the incorrect language appearing in Czech stores. That should not happen. We have identified the issue in the Czech translation layer and have already implemented grammar corrections in the reply notification email. We are also reviewing the handling of reviewer names in subject lines, particularly considering Czech vocative rules, to ensure the wording is linguistically correct and natural. We truly appreciate your detailed feedback and corrections, it has helped us improve the translations properly rather than applying a temporary workaround. Our goal is to fix this permanently at the system level so it does not require additional troubleshooting on your side. Thank you again for your patience and for helping us get this right.

2 / 5 Share
Jan. 30, 2026

I have been trying out your product to see if I wanted to buy a premium paid version. I just hand wrote 40 emails to existing customers asking for reviews. I used the link invitation that goes to my own website as it's higher trust for my customers. A few of them have just reported the link doesn't work. I've tried it and it doesn't consistently for me either. I have lost the chance of good reviews and look incompetent in front of my customers. I'd like you to fix this or I'll go to another app. Your own internal submit review button doesn't work. Absurd!!!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Ballavimus About 2 months 2 3.5
Developer Reply

We’re really sorry to hear about this frustrating experience, especially when you took the time to personally reach out to customers and then ran into issues with the review link and verification. We completely understand how important it is to have a smooth and trustworthy review flow. We’ve already followed up with you privately and are actively investigating the specific cases you mentioned. In some situations, reviews submitted directly through the storefront widget require an additional verification step (and older orders placed before the app was installed may need manual matching), and we’re working with you to get those reviews properly verified. Thank you again for flagging this. Our team is here to make sure everything works reliably and to help you collect reviews with confidence.

2 / 5 Share
Jan. 9, 2026

Overwhelming amount of spam emails sent to the registered email address. Cannot unsubscribe even.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Vivid Hue Over 1 year 1 2.0
Developer Reply

We’re sorry to hear about this, we completely understand how frustrating unwanted emails can be. We’ve already reached out privately to investigate and help stop the messages. If you can share an example of one of the emails you’re receiving, we can identify the source more accurately and make sure the right unsubscribe/stop action is applied. Thanks for flagging this, we’ll prioritize getting it resolved.

2 / 5 Share
Dec. 24, 2025

Not great. not user friendly and helpful with styling. not clear on where the rating can appear and how to do so. the important stuff to a store. y'all feel like a tech company vs human company.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
goldfinch golf 29 days 1 2.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for sharing such thoughtful feedback, we’re really sorry the setup and styling felt unclear and impersonal. We completely understand how important it is for ratings, widgets, and emails to feel intuitive and professional on a live store. We’ve already connected with you privately to go through your concerns in detail, including email styling options, widget placement, and Google ratings syncing, and we’re happy to continue walking through everything together at your pace. Our goal is to make Judge.me feel supportive and human, not complicated or distant. Thanks again for taking the time to explain what didn’t work for you, it truly helps us improve.

2 / 5 Share
Dec. 16, 2025

Our review rate has been much lower with Judge me and they don't send follow up emails if a user didn't open the first email but will if they did. Its backwards logic. I hate that I am not in control of how my customers get emails some programmer is and they always think they know best. I wish we had never used this platform.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Pillow Strap Over 1 year 5 2.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for sharing your honest feedback, we’re truly sorry to hear this has been frustrating, and we completely understand why you’d want more control over how reminder emails are sent. At the moment, our reminder logic is designed to send follow-ups only when a customer has engaged with the initial email, to avoid repeatedly emailing recipients who may never have received or seen the message due to inbox filtering. That said, we absolutely hear your point: in many cases, a reminder to non-openers can be just as (or even more) valuable, and your reasoning is valid. We’ve already reached out to you privately and are escalating your feedback to our core product team for review. While changes to this behavior require careful evaluation, we genuinely appreciate you raising it, it helps us challenge assumptions and improve the product for all merchants.

2 / 5 Share
Dec. 4, 2025

Certes l'app est très utiles, mais devoir payer 15€ par mois pour juste changer la couleur des étoiles c'est trop.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Cozy'Cloud About 2 months 2 3.0
Developer Reply

Merci beaucoup pour votre commentaire! Nous comprenons tout à fait votre point de vue, et nous voulions simplement préciser que le changement de couleur des étoiles est bien disponible dans le plan Gratuit. Vous pouvez modifier la couleur via Paramètres > Marquage > Couleur principale, et cette couleur s’appliquera automatiquement aux étoiles ainsi qu’à d’autres éléments pour garder une identité visuelle cohérente. Nous avons déjà partagé plus de détails avec vous en privé et restons à votre disposition pour vous aider à ajuster les widgets selon vos préférences. Merci encore pour votre avis.

2 / 5 Share
Dec. 1, 2025

Judge.me adverteert met een "gratis" Google My Business integratie, maar dit is pure misleiding. Je kunt je Google Business account verbinden, maar zodra je verbonden bent, ontdek je dat de daadwerkelijke sync functie alleen beschikbaar is voor betalende abonnementen.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
2 / 5 Share
Nov. 15, 2025

new using the app support been great but the app setup keep having issues that i have to keep reaching out to support

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Fason De Viv 6 months 11 4.2
Developer Reply

Thank you for your feedback, and we’re really glad to hear you’ve had a positive experience with our support team. We’re sorry, though, for the repeated setup issues you’ve encountered, that’s not the smooth start we want for you. We’ve already followed up privately to review your widget configuration and make sure everything stays stable going forward.

2 / 5 Share
Nov. 2, 2025

I don’t see any reviews in my store ! I make every step for this and again nothing

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
NECKSERA About 23 hours 1 2.0
2 / 5 Share
Nov. 4, 2025

Too little language support,AliExpress comment import needs optimization, can only be imported by logging in. Comments cannot be displayed

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
ModelHive About 20 hours 3 2.3
2 / 5 Share
Oct. 7, 2025

We have been using the App (paid plan) for months now. Functionality and front end are okay, but the backend literally is unusable due to constant pop ups and spam. Sad to say, but we'll consider moving on.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Grünschloss Almost 2 years 3 2.7
Developer Reply

Thank you for your honest feedback, and we’re truly sorry for the frustration the in-app pop-ups caused. We completely understand how disruptive that can feel, and we appreciate you bringing it to our attention. We’ve already reached out privately to discuss your preferences and can disable all pop-ups and promotional messages for your account if you prefer a cleaner experience. We’ve also shared your feedback with our product and marketing teams to help improve how in-app guidance and updates are delivered in the future. We really value your long-term trust in Judge.me and hope we can make the experience smoother for you moving forward.

Previous Page 1 of 4 Next

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.