LoyaltyLion Loyalty Program for Shopify

LoyaltyLion Loyalty Program

Customer loyalty programs with rewards, tiers & referrals
Rating
4.6
Feedback
541
Reviews
Chart
#348
Shopify

All reviews

1 / 5 Share
Oct. 13, 2026

I have to agree with other reviewers who describe LoyaltyLion’s billing practices as deceptive. I would also describe it as predatory. We were customers for years and spent over $25,000 with them. Before our annual renewal, when I knew I'd be winding down our business soon, I told their Renewals Team I wanted to switch to a monthly subscription. I specifically asked them to confirm we would not be billed for a 12-month plan. They confirmed our billing would be monthly. When I asked to cancel a few months later, they claimed we were actually on another annual contract... just billed monthly. Clearly, that's not what I meant when I asked to switch to a monthly subscription. Even after I explained that our business was closing and provided our public closure announcement, they continued demanding payment and threatened debt collectors. I don't expect companies to act with high morals, but such unethical behavior was shocking to see.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Petit Vour Over 7 years 5 4.2
1 / 5 Share
Sept. 29, 2026

Overpriced software and hard to cancel. They force you into a contract and even when the business shuts down, they make it difficult to cancel. They'll just keep charging you. Predatory. Stay away.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
No B.S. Skin Care Over 2 years 9 3.8
1 / 5 Share
July 8, 2026

DON'T DOWNLOAD THIS APP!! CUSTOMER SERVICE IS GARBAGE AND DISMISSIVE. PREDATORY APP

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Comics Elite Live Over 4 years 1 1.0
Developer Reply

We're sorry to hear that you've had this experience. This certainly isn't the level of service we aim to provide. We've reached out to you directly to better understand your concerns and see how we can help resolve them, and we're currently awaiting your response. We appreciate your feedback and hope to have the opportunity to make things right.

1 / 5 Share
March 9, 2026

App will not let me access anything other than the set up, which is not what I want to do - can not even access their help. Also, I am not able to uninstall the stupid thing. Terrible experience.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
OTRcarry 12 minutes 4 3.3
Developer Reply

Thanks for your feedback, and we're sorry to hear about your experience. Our team is always happy to help if you run into any issues. You can reach us directly at [email protected] or via live chat within the LoyaltyLion platform, and we’ll be glad to assist. We’ve also reached out to you directly to better understand what’s happening and to help resolve this as quickly as possible. If you could please respond to our email, we’d really appreciate the opportunity to support you further and get this sorted.

1 / 5 Share
Jan. 26, 2026

Worst support possible. Spent thousands of dollars and app is still not working. There are much better alternatives for half the price.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Özel Beslenme 11 months 24 3.9
Developer Reply

Thank you for sharing. We take all feedback seriously and I have reviewed your requests with our team. Your dedicated Onboarding Manager is actively working with you to resolve any outstanding items, and our VP of Customer Success has personally reached out to you twice to offer further support, but we have not yet received a response. We are fully committed to supporting you and guiding you through to a successful launch. Please respond to the outreach from our VP of Customer Success so that we can help further

1 / 5 Share
Nov. 26, 2025

This apps works great until I noticed that their SDK causing performance throttling. They have added their Font inside the SDK, and this is impacting performance issue. There is an option to that you can disable custom fonts in SDK but it is actually not working. I have address this to support and they told me that this feature is not available for Free users. Basically they are slowing your website if you are not Paid customer. They are misleading their Free tier and false advertise about their Tier features. dissapointed.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Faylit 5 months 4 3.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback. We’re currently in active conversation with you via support to address the concerns you’ve raised. To clarify, we do not degrade performance for Free plan users in any way. The LoyaltyLion widget is designed to be lightweight and easy to install for free plan businesses starting out, and this is the first report we have received regarding a performance issue related to font loading. We’re exploring options to hide the "disable font" setting that aren’t applicable to the Free plan. We appreciate your feedback and are committed to improving the experience for all merchants. If you have any questions about this, our support team is always happy to help.

1 / 5 Share
Nov. 15, 2025

Have been using the app for years and was satisfied, however the price increases are outrageous and there's 0 chance that i would pay them $200 a month when we have been on a free plan for ages. The Predatory price increase is insane, time to find a new loyalty program that will be loyal to its users.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Avernic Smoke Shop About 5 years 1 1.0
Developer Reply

Hi Jon. We have reached out directly by email to see how we can help resolve this for you. Our free plan is available for stores processing up to a specific number of orders. It's great to see your store is doing well above the order threshold for our free plan and we're happy to move you on to the right size plan for your requirements, which will also come with additional features to further support your business growth. Please respond to our email so we can help

1 / 5 Share
April 10, 2024

The customer service once you have the app installed and are paying them the monthly fee is non existent. I joined in October 2023 - they pulled a price of $583 per month out of the air, after having asked me what my monthly turnover and AOV was. Now that they have joined the App Store I see that I am being over charged. Not only that but during the on boarding call I took the advice of their staff member - he forgot some crucial details and I cannot get anyone to fix it. So basically I have sent 10 emails with no response whatsoever and I have to now disable the Loyalty on my business. If they do not respond in the next few hours I am deleting it - even though from previous reviews I have read they make this next to impossible also. So my advice is stick to Smile.io. I wish I had.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Tailored Equestrian 6 months 10 4.6
Developer Reply

Thanks for taking the time to review our product and service. Firstly, I would like to apologise if our service hasn’t met your expectations. I’m aware that our Customer Success Director has reached out regarding your pricing concerns via email. I wanted to address any concerns you have regarding the communication you have received from us. I wanted to highlight that our team have actively responded to your questions and concerns, and are happy to continue to do so, to help resolve any issues you may have. We look forward to continuing to help you.

1 / 5 Share
March 26, 2024

Very expensive app which does not do justice to the spend. It shows you how much the member spend, but it does not say anything about the costs you are putting in, so you really do not know if it paying off unless you do the detailed calculation yourself. AND; worse of all -it is impossible to cancel! I try to cancel, get a error message on the page in the app several times, contact the support, they say somebody will help you and then you hear nothing more. And the next payment is due. Very little trustworthy, I would even call it a scam. Stay away!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
HouseofDogs.no About 2 years 9 3.4
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to provide feedback. I understand one of our Account Managers is working with your team directly to resolve the issues and support you moving forward. Please let us know if we can support in any other way.

1 / 5 Share
Dec. 25, 2023

I recently installed the application for a new site. The application has many useful things. But I am hugely disappointed by the fact that if my store does not use a significant circulation language (English, French, Spanish) the program does not offer the possibility to do the translation yourself except for the amount of $10 per month, attention! every month not a single fee! (which would still be easier to accept) but why wouldn't it be free since I still make it and not the support team. You disappointed me badly with this fee! It seems to me that you promote discrimination!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
MIGSHOP.RO About 1 month 2 3.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to provide feedback. Our Onboarding lead is keen to connect with you regarding your experience so far and has been emailing you to help, but is yet to receive a response. We do use a third party for managing translations within the app, which is why it is a separate fee. If we could do this for free, we absolutely would. We are still keen to help turn your experience around and have a number of options available to you so please do get in touch either in response to our previous emails or at [email protected]

1 / 5 Share
July 25, 2023

Have been trying to remove app from my store for days now and cancel my subscription. There’s no way to remove the app yourself with out the developer contacting you first . I’ve left several message with the app that I want to cancel my subscription and remove the app from my store but I’m being ignored . This app is very expensive over $400 a month and impossible to remove once installed . Shopify support is no help on this issue either . Please cancel my subscription and remove the app from my store .

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Blink outside the box About 4 years 1 1.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for your review! one of our Key Account Managers will be in touch to assist you with this shortly! As per previous communication - as you are billed via Shopify, this will need to be cancelled with them. Our team will assist you in resolving this! We apologise for any inconvenience experienced.

1 / 5 Share
May 17, 2023

During the sales process we were contacted on an almost weekly basis to get us to sign up. Since signing up, we've received pretty limited levels of support since the onboarding process was complete. When trying to schedule time for a quick call to walk through things, we get avoided and passed on to other people. Be prepared to figure this all out on your own if you do go ahead with it. We're left pretty disappointed, especially given the cost and will look for alternatives before investing too much more in this.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Grub Club Pets 3 months 1 1.0
Developer Reply

Sorry to hear your have received a poor experience, I understand our Head Of Onboarding is working with your team directly to resolve the issues and support you moving forward. Please let us know if we can support in any other way!

1 / 5 Share
May 13, 2023

Lack of customer support. Super slow response time on live chat. Tried to get a hold of someone to help us get set up for a few weeks now. Few calls of mine scheduled on their calendars were cancelled on their end. We just want to cancel and still haven't gotten a hold of anyone. Horrible, just horrible. Yotpo has the same features at half the price. Can't wait to be done with loyaltylion app. Hopefully this negative review gets them to get in contact with me to help with cancellation.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
WAMA Underwear 3 months 10 4.2
Developer Reply

Dear WAMA Underwear, Sorry to hear you have had a bad experience. Our Account Management department have sent a number of calendar invite links to your team to book in some time to discuss the initial upgrade you enquired about and then to discuss the cancelation request logged. I believe someone on your team had originally booked a call in with the outbound sales team (responsible for new customers) but as you are an existing customer - this call needed to happen with the account management team (responsible for existing customers). This is why the scheduled call was cancelled, As highlighted we have sent a number of requests for a call since then. Please respond to our latest email so we can help rectify the issue.

1 / 5 Share
March 21, 2023

Terrible. My account did not work for 6 months. They never helped and no refund for it. They still have not responded to me.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
LingerieDiva About 5 years 2 3.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback with us. I’m sorry to hear that your experience hasn’t met your expectations on this occasion. We are always there to help our customers. I’ve shared this with the team and we will be reaching out to you shortly. Please do reach out [email protected] as well if you need anything further.

1 / 5 Share
Feb. 13, 2023

Installed the program about 4 months ago, but the feedback from clients is very poor. Contacted the sales rep who sold it to me and asked 2 questions: 1. If we can analyse the bad performance together, but very disappointing I was being told LoyaltyLion doesn't do "performance" calls. This was the same person I spoke to about 40 times before signing up for one year. 2. Asked him how can I cancel my subscription (don't want any unexpected auto-renewals) and again very disappointing I was told I need to contact support. Contacted support few days ago but until now no answer. Find it kind of strange all this companies where you can not actually cancel what you signed for with a click of a button. 3. The widget button covers the call to action on my cart drawer, asked them how can I move the widget up and I was told at the moemnt this is not possible. To sumarize: cancelation policy not very clear, program doesn't perform well and the widget button covers the Checkout button ! Very, very disapointed ! Don't recommend this app !

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Delumani 4 months 8 3.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for sharing this honest feedback. We apologize as this is not the experience we'd like anyone to have.. Please know that our team is working to better this. Please be on the lookout for an email from our team so we can work to find the best resolution for you!

1 / 5 Share
Jan. 2, 2023

Do NOT waste your time or money. OR just stick to the FREE version and fully test it for 6 months before upgrading. This company has overcharged me $187 since April, a total of $1683. A refund was finally provided in December, months later. Customers are confused on how to use loyalty points, and the entire program has been a much bigger headache than ever anticipated. They make it seem extremely simple to customize and set up during the sales process, but once you sign the contract, you quickly realize that you will need to hire a web developer to make such customized changes. They will not assist you with the customized changes. After the initial onboarding, you will never hear from support again, regardless what plan you are on. Our plan was $720 a month, complete waste of money. You are only attracting people who want things for FREE. Our loyal customers will be loyal regardless whether they earn points/rewards.

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
STYLES BY SOMA 10 months 6 4.3
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback. I’m so sorry to hear you had a frustrating experience. We apologize that our service did not meet your expectations. Your comments allow us the opportunity to do better. We have looked into the issue and believe we have a resolve for this isolated incident. We hope that this incident doesn't stop you from giving us another chance. We've located your details and we're getting in touch now to solve any issues you may have.

1 / 5 Share
June 17, 2022

I have only given 1 star because I can't give zero. I wish my team had done their homework. LL onboarding is absolutely atrocious. I have received better customer service from apps I pay 1/5th of the price for. The features are not flash at all - go to Stamped. We did. I am much happier

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
ATP Science 4 months 1 1.0
Developer Reply

I really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us. I’m sorry to hear that you were dissatisfied with our service and would like to further follow up with you to support your concerns. Thank you for also pointing out the different ways to improve our service in the future. I want to assure you that your constructive feedback does not go unnoticed. It is valuable information for our whole team, so please do not hesitate to reach out with any further comments or questions.

1 / 5 Share
Oct. 2, 2021

I used this app for about 9 months but the results were not what I expected. In fact I just added two extra costs, one was the cost of the discounts I offered to my customers constantly and the other was the cost of the app. I think that you can offer much more to your customers without the second additional cost, investing in the improvement of the whole customer's experience. In fact, by using an app like Loyalty Lion you don' t increase the loyalty of your customers, but you only attract customers who are only interested in getting rewards. And that is not the definition of loyalty. Finally, while I had already uninstalled the application from my Shopify account, I saw a €10 charge because I had to go to the app page and uncheck the language customisation option which were located in the seventh tab (FOR AN APP I DO NOT USE ANYMORE).

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
Enallaktiko.gr 9 months 4 4.0
Developer Reply

We're very sorry to hear that you didn't get what you expected from the program, we wish you the best with your customer retention strategy going forwards. Regarding your subscription charges, our team did investigate these internally but was unable to find any attributed to your account. If you would like to discuss this further (and any refund), please feel free to reply to our outreach email and we can resolve this shortly.

1 / 5 Share
March 2, 2021

When Is signed up they said someone will help me install, none of that happened, and the chat is also not very helpful :-( The app itself very good but the support not very!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
OrchidRepublic 4 months 5 4.2
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are sorry to read this, a member of our Support team has been in touch over email so please check your inbox as we'd love to resolve this

1 / 5 Share
Jan. 20, 2021

Misleading information on pricing. eg. 'Stores on our free plan can send customized loyalty emails'. This is extremely unhelpful if you are then charging 59$ for this 'enhancement'. Better transparency on pricing before install, please!!

Store Using app Total reviews Average rating
WALLAROO 42 minutes 1 1.0
Developer Reply

Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review! Our free plan allows you to start small with our core features and add individual paid features such as emails only as you need them. We give every store that signs up a free trial so that you have the opportunity to use these features before choosing to add them to your plan. However, being as transparent as possible is really important to us here at LoyaltyLion and so I've passed this really valuable feedback along to our Marketing team to discuss how we can strive to be even more transparent for the future 💫

Previous Page 1 of 2 Next

Sign up to receive AppNavigator updates

Find out when we add keyword-monitoring, review RSS feeds and more.